ASK: I don't know. I mean, the animation's good and Chel's proportions are reasonably accurate. But I've got a real problem with her face. I don't know, maybe it's just bad lighting. But there is something about her face that is just not working.
forwardmarch: I believe the issue is the head turning one way while the body goes the other. Like the creator tried to make her belly dance while riding. I think if she was not twisting and turning, it'd take the animation from fine to great.
Sinael: The whole bottom part of her face is protruding too much forward. It looks fine in 2D, but needs to be adapted and edited to be more in line with the rest of her face to look right in 3D
Comments
I think Chel looks pretty good here, but it can also be boiled down to subjective perspective. Different strokes (ba dum pish) for different folks.
*hottake*